This week on MIP: DABUS endgame, litigation funder battle

Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

This week on MIP: DABUS endgame, litigation funder battle

Generative AI.jpeg

We provide a rundown of Managing IP’s news and analysis coverage from the week, and review what’s been happening elsewhere in IP

AI can’t invent, UK Supreme Court rules

The UK Supreme Court ruled unanimously that only people, not artificial intelligence tools, can be named as inventors under UK patent law.

The keenly awaited decision, on Wednesday, December 20, was a final defeat for the legal team behind the so-called DABUS case that sought to establish an AI tool as the inventor of a food storage system.

Click here to read more

Lawyers battle over litigation funder’s role in Microsoft patent dispute

A lawyer has asked to withdraw from a patent dispute involving Microsoft, citing a conflict with a litigation funder and allegedly unpaid fees.

William Ramey, a lawyer at Ramey LLP, filed a motion at the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit in which he asked to withdraw himself from CTD Networks v Microsoft.

Click here to read more

Other articles published by Managing IP this week include:

UK govt: AI inventorship reform must be global

Weekly take: Why 2023 was a mixed bag for the IP legal market

The IP Lounge: The top 50 in IP 2023, year in review

Five minutes with … Hiroyuki Hagiwara, Paul Hastings

Sources: IP lawyers well-placed to handle China’s diminishing judicial transparency

Behind the case: How Hungry Jack’s overcame TM beef over burger names

Elsewhere in IP

Watch stopped

Apple paused sales of some smart watches on Monday, December 18, amid a high-profile patent infringement row with medical technology company Masimo.

The US International Trade Commission imposed an import ban on the watches earlier this year after Apple was found to have infringed Masimo’s patents.

But that decision is subject to a potential veto by President Joe Biden, who has until December 25 to decide whether the ban should stand.

Apple said it was pausing sales of the allegedly infringing Apple Watch models as a pre-emptive measure.

Fantasy lawsuit

Amazon and the estate of fantasy writer JRR Tolkien have won a US copyright suit brought by the author of a so-called “sequel” to ‘Lord of the Rings’.

Demetrious Polychron filed the suit at the District Court for the District of California, claiming that Amazon’s “The Rings of Power” series copied his book “The Fellowship of the King”.

But Polychron’s complaint backfired when the Tolkien estate filed a countersuit for copyright infringement.

Judge Steven Wilson awarded Amazon and the Tolkien family $134,637 in attorney’s fees after finding Polychron’s suit was “frivolous from the beginning”.

SPC refusal

Merck has missed out on a supplementary protection certificate for multiple sclerosis drug cladribine after a defeat at the England and Wales High Court on Tuesday, December 19.

The UKIPO refused to grant the SPC for the drug, for which the patent will expire in December 2025, after finding Merck didn’t qualify under the Court of Justice of the EU’s Santen decision, issued in 2020.

Merck argued that it developed its cladribine product with the “legitimate expectation” that it would be entitled to an SPC under Neurim, an earlier CJEU decision from 2012.

But King's counsel Michael Tappin, sitting as a deputy high court judge, criticised this argument.

Price tag

The Unified Patent Court’s Munich Local Division refused to grant a preliminary injunction in a lawsuit over patents covering electronic price tags on Wednesday, December 20.

Judge Matthias Zigann said the court wasn’t satisfied that electronics company SES-imagotag’s patent was infringed by competitor Hanshow Technology.

The written order has yet to be published.

That's it for 2023, see you again next year. We wish you all a happy festive period and new year.

more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

The England and Wales appeals court handed down its judgment just seven working days after hearing the trademark dispute involving pharma company Merck
A host of law firms from across Europe and beyond helped bring the streaming technology dispute to a close
Hugues Derème, director general of the Benelux IP Office, unveils his vision for the region, how to improve IP awareness, and use of AI
A copyright win for AI firm Anthropic and a new executive order against law firm Jenner & Block were also among the top talking points this week
A principal at Schwegman Lundberg & Woessner explains how AI tools, including DeepIP, can position the firm to help clients
The firm explains why AI-empowered data analytics could make it a more efficient advocate for its clients
Penelope Aspinall, of IP wellbeing charity Jonathan’s Voice, explains why managers should take a three-tiered approach to looking after workers’ mental health
Heath Hoglund talks about the value proposition of patent pools and why it went ahead with its first-ever series of pool meetings in China
Ryan Richardson, Chris O’Brien, and Jean Selep of Sterne Kessler analyse the treatment of SEPs at the UPC and ITC and highlight why SEP holders and implementers should be mindful of current developments in both forums
A ruling concerning the UPC’s jurisdiction, questions over costs transparency, and a missed deadline by Amazon were among the top talking points this fortnight
Gift this article