UPC judge: ADR centre should favour mediation over arbitration

Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

UPC judge: ADR centre should favour mediation over arbitration

AdobeStock_290704340 (1).jpeg

Sam Granata led a panel discussion on the new Patent Mediation and Arbitration Centre, which will open alongside the UPC in June

An alternative dispute resolution centre attached to the Unified Patent Court should focus on mediation over arbitration, a judge at the court suggested yesterday, January 10.

Sam Granata, who will be a judge at the UPC local division in Brussels, was speaking at an online event hosted by the Munich Intellectual Property Dispute Resolution Forum.

A panel that also included senior in-house counsel at InterDigital and Xiaomi explored the role of the Patent Mediation and Arbitration Centre (PMAC), which will be part of the UPC.

The centre, which will have bases in Slovenia and Portugal, will provide staff and facilities to help parties who wish to resolve cases out of court or are advised to do so by a judge.

Its scope includes mediation between parties and the appointment of arbitrators to resolve disputes.

Granata, who is also a judge at the Court of Appeal in Antwerp, said he was a strong believer in mediation but was reluctant to send parties to arbitrators, who are effectively in competition with courts.

“It’s as if the hunter directed the parties to the poacher,” he said.

The judge was more optimistic about the potential for PMAC mediators to help resolve disputes, especially those related to damages and costs.

Granata also urged court officials to ensure UPC judges are trained as mediators.

“It helps judges to see how mediation works and they also learn valuable communication skills,” he said.

In-house perspective

Counsel at InterDigital and Xiaomi both agreed that the PMAC would need to have a tight focus on core issues to be successful.

ZiAng Zhuang, director of IP and litigation at Xiaomi in Beijing, said disputes over fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory (FRAND) royalties were often too complex to be resolved quickly via arbitration.

“There are issues to be worked through with arbitration but alternative dispute resolution (ADR) is not a one-size-fits-all solution, especially for FRAND disputes,” he said.

Steve Akerley, head of IP and litigation at InterDigital in Delaware, said ADR had to remain efficient in order to be attractive.

“If the PMAC is intended to cover infringement and validity, that removes some of the efficiencies we typically see in international arbitrations,” he said.

If PMAC arbitrations operated at the same efficiency level as the UPC, parties would prefer the UPC because they would retain the right to appeal, Akerley added.

The UPC is scheduled to open on June 1, following a series of delays.

more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

Florina Firaru discusses making new connections, the art of flower arranging, and the biggest misconception about IP
The firm, which appointed three IP partners from A&O Shearman, wants to develop a tier one practice in Europe
The England and Wales appeals court handed down its judgment just seven working days after hearing the trademark dispute involving pharma company Merck
A host of law firms from across Europe and beyond helped bring the streaming technology dispute to a close
Hugues Derème, director general of the Benelux IP Office, unveils his vision for the region, how to improve IP awareness, and use of AI
A copyright win for AI firm Anthropic and a new executive order against law firm Jenner & Block were also among the top talking points this week
A principal at Schwegman Lundberg & Woessner explains how AI tools, including DeepIP, can position the firm to help clients
The firm explains why AI-empowered data analytics could make it a more efficient advocate for its clients
Penelope Aspinall, of IP wellbeing charity Jonathan’s Voice, explains why managers should take a three-tiered approach to looking after workers’ mental health
Heath Hoglund talks about the value proposition of patent pools and why it went ahead with its first-ever series of pool meetings in China
Gift this article