Vidal says OpenSky abused IPR process in billion-dollar case

Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Vidal says OpenSky abused IPR process in billion-dollar case

Kathi Vidal

In a director review decision, the USPTO chief said OpenSky’s attempt to extract payment from VLSI and Intel and undermine proceedings was a violation

USPTO director Kathi Vidal slapped down patent challenger OpenSky today, October 4, for abusing the inter partes review process at the Patent Trial and Appeal Board in a case worth more than $2 billion.

In her director review decision, Vidal said OpenSky violated the process by attempting to extract payment from patent owner VLSI and joint petitioner Intel and offering to undermine proceedings in exchange.

“Taken together, the behaviour warrants sanctions to the fullest extent of my power,” Vidal wrote. “Not only are such sanctions proportional to the conduct here, but they are necessary to deter such conduct by OpenSky or others in the future.”

She sanctioned the patent challenger by blocking it from actively participating in the IPR and temporarily elevating Intel to the position of lead petitioner in the OpenSky v VLSI dispute.

Vidal also demanded that OpenSky make a case for why it shouldn’t be ordered to pay compensatory damages to VLSI, including attorney fees.

The director didn’t dismiss the proceeding but ordered, in an effort to balance the competing interests at issue, that the case be remanded to the PTAB to determine whether the petition presented a compelling and meritorious challenge.

The board should make the decision within the next two weeks, she said, based only on the record before the PTAB prior to institution.

Vidal accepted the case for director review after VLSI, a non-practising entity owned by investment funds managed by the Fortress Investment Group, alerted the PTAB to an email it received from OpenSky last March.

The email suggested that the two “work together to secure dismissal or defeat” and that OpenSky might agree not to pay its expert to appear at a deposition as part of the deal, according to VLSI.

OpenSky, which was incorporated in April 2021, challenged VLSI’s patent at the PTAB shortly after the NPE won a $2.18 billion jury verdict against Intel at the District Court for the Western District of Texas in March 2021.

The PTAB instituted the challenge in December 2021, having previously denied a similar petition brought by Intel on discretionary grounds.

more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

Karl Barnfather’s new patent practice will focus on protecting and enforcing tech innovations in the electronics, AI, and software industries
Partner Ranjini Acharya explains how her Federal Circuit debut resulted in her convincing the court to rule that machine learning technology was not patent-eligible
Paul Hastings and Smart & Biggar also won multiple awards, while Baker McKenzie picked up a significant prize
Burford Capital study finds that in-house lawyers have become more likely to monetise patents, but that their IP portfolios are still underutilised
Robert Reading and Faidon Zisis at Clarivate unpick some of the data surrounding music-related trademarks
China's latest IP litigation statistics and a high-profile hire by O'Melveny were also among the top talking points this week
David Aylen, who spent more than 20 years at Gowling WLG, has joined United Trademark and Patent Services as of counsel in the UAE
Europe is among the most lucrative legal markets for PE firms to bet on, but clients’ reactions will decide whether external investment drives success
Rulings of note covered pre-June 2023 infringements and jurisdiction over non-UPC states, while winners of Managing IP’s EMEA Awards acted in multiple cases
Jason Blair, a former special marks examiner, said Dykema’s Texas presence will help him build deeper connections with clients
Gift this article