US Supreme Court loosens fee shifting standard in Octane and Highmark decisions

Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Cookies Settings

US Supreme Court loosens fee shifting standard in Octane and Highmark decisions

April 29 2014

The Supreme Court has unanimously reversed the Federal Circuit and rejected the Brooks Furniture framework for fee shifting in Octane v Icon, while holding that all aspects of a district court’s exceptional-case determination should be reviewed for abuse of discretion in Highmark v Allcare

Unlock this content.

The content you are trying to view is exclusive to our subscribers.

To unlock this content:

Take a Free Trial or Login

Topics

United StatesNewsPatentsNorth AmericaJurisdictions
more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

Patents
VenableMarchPeopleMove.png
IP litigators look forward to wider offering at Venable
One of the litigators expects that she’ll have to help clients navigate challenges posed by USPTO developments
Rani Mehta, March 13 2025
Patents
Flat illustration of businessman looking through binoculars at lightbulb idea seeking to discover new solutions and opportunities
Firms eye ITC opportunities post-Lashify ruling
Counsel explain what kind of ITC-related inquiries they’re getting from clients and why complaints at the forum were up in 2024
Rani Mehta, March 13 2025
Patents
An electric citrus juicer with a compact design, placed on a plain white surface for a sharp presentation.
UPC update: Juicy Mannheim ruling | Cases tick past 750
A ruling concerning a juicing machine, a tussle over a preliminary injunction and a new judge in Paris were among the top talking points this fortnight
Max Walters, March 13 2025
Patents
uspto20campus.jpg
Ex-Perkins Coie and Goldman Sachs lawyer named next USPTO chief
John Squires has had a range of in-house and private practice experience, most recently in the IP group at Dilworth Paxson
Max Walters, March 12 2025
Patents
Female hand with megaphone on white background
Weekly take: Counsel should speak out against Trump’s attacks on firms
President Donald Trump’s attacks on Perkins Coie and Covington & Burling should not go unchallenged
Rani Mehta, March 12 2025
Patents
merger-comp.jpg
Exclusive: Australia’s Foundry IP and Davis IP to join forces
The combined entity, which is expected to offer IP services across Australia and New Zealand, will be called Jones Maxwell Smith & Davis
Sukanya Sarkar, March 11 2025
Trademarks
Thailand - 26 September 2023 : Umbro sport brand is release the new football shoe "Tocco III" which is design for control and touch performance which is made from soft leather. Close-up.
Bird & Bird and Brandsmiths prepare for ‘double diamond’ battle
The Iconix v Dream Pairs dispute, to be heard at the UK Supreme Court, concerns trademarks owned by sports brand Umbro and the issue of post-sale confusion
Max Walters, March 11 2025
Trademarks
Twins Men Beards
Look out for look-a-likes: perspectives from across Europe
The European IP team from Simmons & Simmons discusses the current approaches to IP enforcement against look-a-like or copycat products
Joel Smith, March 11 2025
Patents
EMEA The most nominated firms in 2025_2x (1).png
Managing IP EMEA Awards 2025: which firms appear the most?
Ten firms have each received more than 11 nominations, while more than 20 in-house counsel are up for awards
Max Walters, March 11 2025
Patents
Yanfeng.jpg
Five Minutes With…Yanfeng Xiong, China Patent Agent (HK)
Yanfeng Xiong discusses 6am wake ups, honing his basketball skills, and how he prioritises tasks
March 10 2025
Gift this article