Who’s really shaping the troll debate?

Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Who’s really shaping the troll debate?

Yesterday’s Congressional hearing featured witnesses from the high-tech, pharma and legal industries. But maybe we should look elsewhere for the real influencers

Patent reform has been front and centre in Washington DC in the past week, following the publication of Chairman Goodlatte’s Innovation Act (whatever you think about US legislative proposals, you have to admire the branding – who can possibly oppose the principle of an Innovation Act?).

That was announced with a flurry on Wednesday, and at the AIPLA Annual Meeting on Thursday and Friday everyone was talking about it (see our daily newspapers for more detail). Yesterday, Goodlatte’s Judiciary Committee held a hearing with testimony from Krish Gupta of EMC, Kevin Kramer of Yahoo, former USPTO Director David Kappos and Robert Armitage, recently retired from Eli LIlly. Behind the scenes, representatives of technology companies and law associations are busy haggling over the plans with Congressional staff and lawyers.

Whatever they think about the details of the bill, Managing IP readers might be pleased to see that it is in the safe hands of people whose professional interest is IP. But just pause for a moment.

When the bill was published last week, who were the first people to welcome its proposals? Step forward bodies such as the National Restaurant Association, the National Retail Federation and the American Hotel & Lodging Association. These represent many companies, often the legendary “mom’n’pop” stores, who claim they are big victims of trolls, and are being targeted by frivolous lawsuits based on dubious patent claims alleging that they make use of computers, software or other technology that is infringing

Sure, certain tech companies want patent reform – some of them were represented at the hearing today. But the restaurants, hotels and stores want it even more. And some say it’s those groups that have real influence on the Administration and in Congress. One person close to the debate in Washington DC told me last week that they are the ones who Representatives and Senators will listen to, not least because they speak for a large number of businesses in members’ constituencies and have a well-established lobbying presence that is very good at articulating their concerns.

You might think that the sensitive topic of patent reform is best left to those who are involved in IP day-in and day-out. On the other hand, you might welcome the involvement of groups outside of the traditional IP-intensive industries, who can bring some perspective to the debate. Either way, it’s worth remembering that when politicians debate and, ultimately, vote on these sorts of issues there are many influences on them outside of the ones that we in the IP world are familiar with. And some of those influences might be very powerful.



more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

Yanfeng Xiong discusses 6am wake ups, honing his basketball skills, and how he prioritises tasks
Saina Shamilov explains how she convinced the Federal Circuit to upend the US ITC’s domestic industry analysis
Christopher Kinkade and Naira Simmons reveal the distributed firm’s hiring hopes for 2025, a little more than a year after it was founded
A CJEU copyright decision on employees' rights and an update on an IP feud concerning foreign rights over 'Superman' were also among the top talking points
Counsel explain how firms advising PTAB petitioners may react to the USPTO’s decision to ditch Fintiv guidance
The recruits include another former Stobbs lawyer, as well as a chief technology officer and chief financial officer
Jeffrey Saltman, who is anticipating a continued ‘ramping up’ of 5G patent litigation, has joined Cole Schotz
We look ahead to next month’s EMEA Awards, discussing the recently published shortlists, our research methodology and what makes the Awards special
EIP also emerged victorious as the England and Wales Court of Appeal backed a challenge brought by Avanci and InterDigital against the electric carmaker
Madeleine Kelly, the Australia-based IP firm’s new managing partner, discusses its new advisory offering, a promising fresh hire and changing market dynamics
Gift this article