India: Arbitrability of IP issues

Managing IP is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

India: Arbitrability of IP issues

In a recent judgment of October 2017, a Division Bench of the Madras High Court in Lifestyle Equities CV v QDSeatoman Designs Pvt. Ltd & Ors has held that IP issues could be subject to arbitration. The fundamental point at dispute was whether and to what extent are IP related rights arbitrable given that they tend to have effect in rem.

The case concerned a commercial agreement between the parties, whereby QDSeatoman Designs Pvt Ltd, and Quintessential Designs India Pvt Ltd (collectively referred to as "QDS") were engaged by Lifestyle Equities for certain creative services, relating to apparel and garments. This obviously covered IP. This agreement contained an arbitration clause. Certain disputes arose between the parties, though the judgment is not entirely clear on the exact details and circumstances.

Lifestyle Equities invoked the arbitration clause in the matter whereas QDS opposed the same on the ground that the disputes involve IP issues and thus, non-arbitrable. Instead, QDS wanted the Court to permit the filing of a civil suit.

In its judgment dated October 13 2017, the Court held that the issue boiled down to whether the issues being raised would result in a judgment / award in rem or in personam; the former is not arbitrable, but the latter is. According to the Court, the distinction between a right in rem and a right in personam is very old and well-defined one – a judgment in personam refers to a judgment against a person, whereas a judgment in rem refers to a judgment against a thing, right or status or condition of property. In the context of IP, the Court held that a patent licence issue may be arbitrable, but validity of the underlying patent may not be arbitrable.

On facts, the Division Bench agreed with the opinion of the Learned Single Judge, which was under appeal, that the fundamental dispute between the parties related to who had the better right of usage vis-a-vis the other and that this was clearly an issue in personam.

Even though the Hon'ble Court concluded that the dispute between the parties was arbitrable, the Arbitral Tribunal so constituted nevertheless had the jurisdiction to decide its own competence and thus, the final decision on the issue would have to be that of the Arbitral Tribunal.

R Parthasarathy

Lakshmi Kumaran & Sridharan

B6/10 Safdarjung Enclave

New Delhi 110029, India

Tel: +91 11 41299800

Fax:91 11 41299899

vlakshmi@lakshmisri.com

www.lslaw.in

more from across site and SHARED ros bottom lb

More from across our site

Paul Hastings and Smart & Biggar also won multiple awards, while Baker McKenzie picked up a significant prize
Burford Capital study finds that in-house lawyers have become more likely to monetise patents, but that their IP portfolios are still underutilised
Robert Reading and Faidon Zisis at Clarivate unpick some of the data surrounding music-related trademarks
China's latest IP litigation statistics and a high-profile hire by O'Melveny were also among the top talking points this week
David Aylen, who spent more than 20 years at Gowling WLG, has joined United Trademark and Patent Services as of counsel in the UAE
Europe is among the most lucrative legal markets for PE firms to bet on, but clients’ reactions will decide whether external investment drives success
Rulings of note covered pre-June 2023 infringements and jurisdiction over non-UPC states, while winners of Managing IP’s EMEA Awards acted in multiple cases
Jason Blair, a former special marks examiner, said Dykema’s Texas presence will help him build deeper connections with clients
Lee Curtis and Rachel Platts at HGF discuss the rise of the ‘intention economy’ and its impact on trademark law
Martin Wintermeier discusses taking a hit for clients, not letting stress get to you, and why being a criminal defence lawyer might have been fun
Gift this article